Sometimes I replenish my whiskey bottles with water
And swirl it around. I drink up
To make sure I didn’t miss a single drop of that alcohol.
Diluted or not, I ache for it.
Grief.
But not as much as I ache for you.
I would rinse you out and sip all of your insides.
Then I would drag your skeleton out of your skin.
Help me. Worm your way free.
Grief,
My love.
I would jumble our bones together. Mix us up.
Not so we would be two with replaced bones.
No, I want us to have four arms, four legs. I want,
I want us to have two heads and a long twisted spine
Of vertebrate upon vertebrate.
I want us to clank out hollow sounds
When we come rambling along.
Our ribcages would be split and spread.
No longer cages, but wings of rib bones.
Your hips would jut against mine
And our fingers would intertwine.
Grief,
My love,
Never leave.
Our skin would not go to waste,
Oh no.
Instead, we would tear them to shreds
And weave them together.
We could nest on them.
With all our empty bottles.
At the beginning of my critiques I like to give my overall impression of the piece before I go into the delicious details. This was astonishingly powerful. I loved the grim tone & the wording overall. You are certainly a wordsmith and I worship your originality.
Now, let's get down and dirty.
There is dark, brooding imagery here that is eerily beautiful. You're addressing one of the most negative parts of the human psyche - and yet it comes across beautifully. I love the turn of phrase and description. Especially -
"I would rinse you out and sip all of your insides.
Then I would drag your skeleton out of your skin."
&
"Our ribcages would be split and spread.
No longer cages, but wings of rib bones."
- gorgeous in the most morbid way.
I really like the concept of this. Not only do you succeed in getting a certain message across - but you create a beat that is unique and all your own. While reading I was forced to pause and say the single word aloud. Grief. It echoed in the room and the chill down my spine confirmed my understanding. Genius, my love.
Now for the constructive feedback:
There are places during your stanzas where you capitalize the beginning of a line even though it's the continuation of the last sentence. In my experience - great poetry with awesome flow & punctuation usually leaves the continuation of a sentence un-capitalized. So, instead of your stanza reading like it did, it could read like this:
"Sometimes I replenish my whiskey bottles with water
and swirl it around. I drink up
to make sure I didn’t miss a single drop of that alcohol.
Diluted or not, I ache for it."
In my opinion, not only is punctuation now correct - but I feel it flows better vocally than it did before.
You did a wonderful job until the large stanzas starting with "I would jumble..." and ending with "...would intertwine." For me - this part of the poem is too jumbled. It would add to your flow & make for better reading were it split up into two separate stanzas. Of course - this is just my opinion and you can choose to disregard it if you wish.
Overall, my dear - this was a beautifully written piece and you are obviously a very accomplished writer. It was a pleasure to critique your work & I hope it was of some help.
I just have a few points to pick out.
Watch out when it comes to plurals and singulars, I noticed a couple of points in this poem where you have been talking about something in the singular and then switch to a plural reference. The last stanza is the most noticeable since you talk about the skins of two people as a singular object and then refer to the skin as them. It only stands out since the skins seems meshed already at the start of the stanza and then you have broken them apart with the 'them'. 'Our skins would not go to waste' would allow for the plurality of 'them'.
I love the image of four arms, four legs. The twisted spine and vertebrate on vertebrate created the most wonderful images and rib bone wings are inspired. I had the fantastic idea of the rib cage creaking and snapping open to make this creepy, skeletal wings.
I didn't think the first two stanzas were as strong though. I thought that the use of 'I drink up' reduced the impact of the image somewhat. Personally, I really wanted a good punch which can be achieved by something as simple as dropping the 'I' and having it as drink up. The later length of the poem wastes no words, yet the first two stanzas don't quite have that same hit.
Overall it is defiantly one of my favorite poems of the moment, well done on a fantastic piece.
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.